Sandwich Day
There used to be this fantastic deli and sandwich shop right down the street from my high school. For four years, I used to save my week’s lunch money and then, on Friday, I would walk there, get a sandwich, and walk home. There was one sandwich in particular that I fell in love with - and the only thing I really knew about it was that it was sliced chicken breast with a delicious horseradish mayo on a freshly baked bun.
When I left for college, I longed for “The Titan.” The sheer brute force of the horseradish flavor was unmatchable. So I waited and waited until I came home on my first break from college.
And the sandwich shop had closed. In fact, the entire plaza where the sandwich shop was housed had shut down.
I eventually found an alternative within the boundaries of my town, but it never matched the flavor and deliciousness of “The Titan.”
So, I decided to figure it out. Once a year, usually within the first few weeks of being home from college, I wander around the supermarket and try to piece together the sandwich I once loved.
Two years ago it was a Portuguese roll, chicken, swiss, lettuce, tomato, and pre-bottled horseradish mayo. And that wasn’t right.
Last year it was chicken, a standard hard roll, cheddar, lettuce, red peppers, tomato, and the same pre-bottled horseradish mayo. Still not right.
This year? I nearly have it right.
The only reason it was close was because, as I’m standing in line for the deli, the woman right before me asked for pepper jack cheese. I’m pretty sure I gasped loud enough that the deli workers thought I saw a hobo forcing a newborn baby to smoke crack. I had actually just realized that pepper jack cheese was the lost flavor. I also bought a bottle of straight-up horseradish, hoping that a homemade mixture would be a better version of the pre-mixed mayo I had tried for the last two years.
I, like a moron, forgot to mix the horseradish with the mayo, so it was a little TOO spicy, but other than that, it was almost exactly “The Titan.”
I’ll have to wait until next spring to try again, but at least this time I know what the right combination is. And I think that’s a suitable college graduation present.
